Grade: B
Synopsis: Toward the end of World War II, a group of German Officers (Tom Cruise, Kenneth Branagh, Bill Nighy, Terence Stamp, and Eddie Izzard) plots a coup involving the assassination of Adolph Hitler.
Valkyrie is a tight, well-done historical drama highlighted by solid performances, tight editing, a good score, and some great lines. Unfortunately, it also suffers from one insurmountable problem: you know how it’s going to end.
The film’s opening might have you believing screenwriters Christopher McQuarrie and Nathan Alexander are conceding this knowledge by starting with the failed assassination and working backwards, but that’s not the case. Instead, they tell the story as a straight thriller, working in as much misdirection as possible in order the keep the audience guessing, but it’s not enough.
For the big scene, the actual assassination attempt, director Bryan Singer channels Alfred Hitchcock in an exquisitely cut sequence that would have you on the edge of your seat… if there was a chance of it actually working. Instead, you’re just waiting to see what goes wrong, which effectively robs the scene of much of its potential.
Indeed, the script’s real strength is everything that happens afterwards. Here, McQuarrie and Alexander manage to shape a powerful and compelling drama as the conspirators try to secure their coup. From here through the surprisingly powerful ending, Valkyrie is really something.
To their credit, the filmmakers do move the story along at a brisk pace, while still allowing the strong cast plenty of time to shine. Despite the plot’s predictability, Valkyrie never bores you. Unfortunately, it never really thrills you either.
One Response on “Valkyrie (2008)”:
Jump to Review Form | Trackback URI
-
Charles Reilly said:
Grade: B
Director Singer and his cast did a fine job with “Valkyrie” and yes we all know how this movie is going to end unless you’re someone who hasn’t picked up a history book in a long time. Maybe a better and more revealing movie on this subject would be one about the horrific end of the conspirators who survived the initial firing squads and had to face the wrath of Hitler and his People’s Court. Von Stauffenberg can consider himself “lucky” for only having to face some rifles at point-blank range. His own brother and many others were tortured to death under the most barbaric circumstances. His wife, Nina, even did some time in a Nazi jail before she was finally released after the war. The true story of Hitler’s terrible revenge on the conspirators of July 1944 can be found on the pages of William Shirer’s “The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich” and other historical books about the Nazi regime. It’s a worthy subject in its own right and one that needs to be told to a broad audience.
